Sunday, April 5, 2015

Silly Patent #1


“Linear Putter Device of a Golf Club” US Patent Number 6659880

This putter involves a connecting rod that fits to person’s chin in order help move the putter in a linear fashion. This patent in the golf industry would definitely be considered silly and very much a gimmick.

Validity:  This patent is valid because it is novel and it is not obvious when it comes to golfers.  There could be some use for someone out there; however, most serious or even occasional golfers would find it to be silly.  

Anticipation: I believe there was little anticipation besides the fact there have been anchored putters to the belly and chest. 

Prior Art: Elongated putters and as listed above, anchored putters to the chest and abdomen are among the prior art. 

Obviousness: This putter that anchors to the chin would not be an obvious tool in golf. 

Potential Infringement: I do not believe that infringement on this product would be probable; however, if infringement were to occur, I doubt revenues from this product would make litigation worth it. 


Patent Trolls Protection Strategies

As discussed in my previous posts, patent trolls are non-practicing entities that seek to gain monetary value by asserting patents on practicing entities.  There are several things that companies do in order to deal with patent trolls, and this post will outline a few of these strategies.

1. When confronted with a patent troll, practicing entities will make sure to require detailed information about exactly is being infringed upon.    

2. Practicing entities will also employ resources to try to find any contradictions with the patent troll and the practice in question.  

3. Practicing entities will try to invalidate the patent altogether by finding a flaw in the patent's claims, reference to prior art, and any other discrepancy.  

4. Larger corporations will more money will draw out litigation and expenses in order to possibly deter the patent troll from continuing the lawsuit.  

5. Companies will often times try to make a lump-sum or other compensation deal out of the courtroom in order to save hassle and expenses. 

As you can see, there are several things that companies and practicing entities can do in order to combat and deal with patent trolls.  In addition, media coverage and exposure to patent trolls and their negative effects can also help curb some of the attacks.  It is necessary to understand that there are ways to effectively combat patent trolls!


Thursday, April 2, 2015

Patent Trolls Examples

As discussed in the previous post, patent trolls attempt to profit by exercising their patents on practicing entities.  In this post, I will be displaying a few examples of patent trolls, as well as some interesting facts about companies who have been affected by patent trolls.

Patent Troll                   Company/Affected Entity                        Patent(s) in Question
1. Intellect Wireless         11 different Mobile Companies              "Wireless Messaging Patent"

2. Blackboard Inc.           Desire2Learn                                "System and Method of online learning"

3. Digitude Innovations   Multiple Software Companies        Several purchased patents from Apple

4. Lodsys                         Multiple Software Developers        "Customer-based product design module"

Patent trolls often target very large businesses, and occur more frequently than one might think.  These companies spend countless dollars during these lawsuits and must employ many resources in developing prevention techniques.  The figures below reflect the amount of times each company was sued in 2013 due to patent trolls.

1. AT&T- 54 times
2. Google- 43 times
3. Verizon- 42 times
4. Apple- 41 times

As you can see, these companies are dealing with patent litigation almost nonstop, which is startling in my opinion.  These figures display the absolute need to reform patent litigation and possibly the patent system as a whole.  Let me know what you guys think!


Patent Litigation by Non Practicing Entities

Patent litigation by non practicing entities are also referred to as patent trolls.  Patent trolls are entities, individuals, or companies whose main business focus is to assert their patents on practicing entities in order to acquire monetary gain.  There are a variety of reasons why patent trolls are prevalent, among which are people who do not have the funds to carry out their invention, people who invent purely to sue larger entities, and people who choose to pursue other endeavors aside from their patents.  There are several key aspects to these patent trolls that make them a nuisance for many large corporations. Among these are the fact that:

1. Patent Trolls can sue anyone, even customers, because they have no customer base that could be affected.
2. Patent Trolls also don't worry about countersuits because they usually do not make enough to be worth the lawsuit.

In addition, patent trolls slow down economic process.  When a patent troll does not exercise the right to use the patent, it creates an environment where no one can benefit from the patent; unless of course the practicing entity pays or comes to an agreement with the patent troll.  Often times the price is too high to make it worth it for the practicing entity, which prohibits the practice of the patent altogether.  There have been several suggestions for combatting patent trolls, among these are:

1. Have stricter guidelines for approving patents.
2. Force patent holders to pay a substantial fee to retain patents
3. Create a system where patent trolls must pay practicing entities' litigation fees should they lose the lawsuit.

I hope this gave you a good idea of patent trolls and I look forward to your comments!






 

Friday, March 13, 2015

Obviousness Part 2

Obviousness Youtube Video:

"Prior art search-Obviousness in your Invention or Idea-Venn Diagrams"
**This video breaks down obviousness into a very interesting and easy to understand way

Major Points to Pull:
  1. There have been many supreme court cases over the last 100 years related to obviousness in patents. (i.e Graham v. John Deere Co.)
  2. Patent practitioners help overcome the finding of obviousness in your patent.
  3. "Prior art searches" look to see if there are overlapping parts of your invention to prior art.  
  4. If entire art overlaps with a prior art, then the invention is not proprietary and is obvious.  
  5. If your patent is rejected, patent practitioner provide arguments to the patent office based on patent law and other aspects of obviousness in practice.  


Obviousness Part 1

I will be discussing obviousness and how it relates to patents in general, summarizing it into 10 key points...


  1. Obviousness is a vital part of the patent system, as it is one specific thing that every inventor must overcome.  The invention cannot be obvious, or common knowledge.  There must be something proprietary about the patent.  
  2. Obviousness is used to allow technological evolution to occur because if patents oversaturate a market, innovators are often deterred from entering the field due to a higher chance of infringements. 
  3. Non-obvious means that someone who has ordinary skills in the art would not have thought of the given invention. 
  4. Non-obviousness also characterizes an invention that is proprietary and that has been deemed worthy of receiving a patent. 
  5. In order to fully analyze obviousness, prior art must also be analyzed in order to determine a proper scope.
  6. In addition, differences between the invention in question and the prior art must be identified. 
  7. When determining obviousness, the level of non-technical skill in the patent in question must be agreed upon.  
  8. Although obviousness is pertinent to patent, there remains much debate on what fully determines what is patentable.  
  9. The Supreme Court qualifies obviousness with  "A person of ordinary skill in the art is also a person or ordinary creativity, not a automaton." 
  10. If something is considered "Obvious to Try," it can also be considered obvious based on its anticipation, common sense, familiarity, or predictability of the results.  
**I hope you liked my summary of obviousness, let me know your thoughts!  


Sunday, March 1, 2015

Patent and Patent Applications Personal Response


For this post, I will be discussing the below patent in terms of their obviousness and anticipation.  My previous post discusses these patents in detail, and can be used to reference specific logistics. 

US 6343735 B1 Insulating sleeve

US 2661889 A  Thermal coffee cup

US 8,251,277 B1 Thermal Sleeve, Method for Manufacturing a thermal sleeve and combination cup container
US 7,922,031 B1  Insulator sleeve for a beverage container
US 8118189 B1  Temperature-indicating sleeve and related container
US 6152363 Sleeve construction for improved paperboard cup insulation

US 20080078824 A1 Beverage cup sleeving system and method

US 20100019023 A1  Protective sleeve

US 20140151385 A1 Hot and Cold Cup Sleeve

In terms of obviousness, these patents seem to be repetitive and very obvious in some cases; however, each patent has a specific feature that makes it novel to the rest.  For instance, the thermal coffee cup was proprietary by its description of the cap’s mechanism, though still referencing prior art.  The temperature-indicating sleeve built upon a previous sleeve but added a component that had yet to be introduced.  The patent dealing with sleeve construction for improved insulation displayed tangible improvements to the air gaps therefore improving the product as a whole.  Each one of these patents was approved because they were novel and useful; so although they overlap and seem identical, they expand on previous inventions that make it proprietary. 

In terms of anticipation, the ones that stick out the most to me are the temperature-indicating sleeve and the hot and cold cup sleeve.  In general, the patents seemed to be very basic and dealing with slide modifications to increase functionality.  Prior patents in particular most likely anticipated these two patents, because a hot and cold sleeve would bring a multi-use product that can save related businesses money.  The temperature-indicating sleeve must have had anticipation because a key property of the sleeve is dealing with temperature-induced discomfort.  In my opinion, it would only make sense to have an indicator that would protect your mouth from the same heat that would be painful to the hand.